
NBC’s Heroes is not a good show. It’s the TV equivalent of candy. It’s a highly manufactured flavor, it’s saccharine, it has no nutritional value, and it’s delicious. It’s bad but it’s entertaining and if you have nothing better to do, it can certainly kill an hour.
But a recent Q&A revealed a clip that will probably have me spitting out this candy in disgust if it turns out to be the wholesale theft it appears to be.
I’m gonna go into spoilers now so if you think Heroes is an edge-of-your-seat serial thriller where you can’t stand to know what happens next, then you probably never saw anything in your life because it’s an insanely predictable show. But creator Tim Kring has sprung quite a surprise in making a move to steal from one of the most seminal comics of all time, Alan Moore’s Watchmen.
If you haven’t read Watchmen, you probably don’t read comics in the first place. If you do read comics but haven’t read Watchmen, you need to BUY IT NOW
. Now I’m hesitant to spoil this comic but it is twenty years old. However, quit reading if you don’t want to know the shocking ending (and it is shocking and incredibly ballsy).
Okay, for those still with me, you have now put two and two together (hopefully). You read the link where the character Linderman reveals he has powers and he and others tried to play superheroes, but it didn’t work out. Now, Linderman will detonate a nuke in New York City to bring the world together; omelet and eggs and all that.
Now if you’ve read Watchmen, you know that the character Ozymandias was a former superhero who kills former “masks” before teleporting a giant alien creature into New York City in order to stop the Cold War and bring the world together; omelet and eggs and all that.
There’s borrowing and there’s theft and Heroes has committed the sin of the latter. The only way it could be stealing more is if Linderman was connected to the super serial-killer Sylar and I certainly wouldn’t put it past Kring to have it shake out that way. Remember, logic and common sense have very little place in the comics-dismissive-yet-wholesale-theft world of Heroes. Blob could glide through the show’s plot holes. Anyone want to explain to me why Hiro lost his powers and why he needs a magical sword to regain them? Anyone? You could argue that it’s a mystery, but the show argues that the mystery is already solved. Lose your powers for some reason? Clearly, you need a special sword! What’s not to get?
But if Watchmen is so important, then how can it be theft? Surely, people will notice! Well, Watchmen is important but it’s not necessarily popular. It’s a comic for grown-ups in a medium that is dominated by stunted men-children. Heroes on the other hand, is like comics without the shame of actually going to a comic shop and purchasing superhero comics (most of which, like Heroes, have the special ability of blowing hard). What sends a chill down my spine is if Zach Snyder’s Watchmen arrives next year, people see it, and then say “It stole from Heroes!” Then again, dumb people say stupid shit all the time. I guess what really upsets me is that Kring has such little respect for such an important book and has a show so creatively bankrupt that they’re going to steal. I suppose the only positive in this is that if you’re going to steal, steal from the best.
While some are hoping that this clip was simply an attempt to mislead fans, my hope is that within context and not as a singular scene, Watchmen will merely serve as the inspiration rather than the script. I would say I’m expecting to be disappointed, but disappointment implies hope, and ever since the second episode, I haven’t had much hope for this unhealthy guilty pleasure of a show.
Tags: comics, stupid, television by Matt
No Comments »